| Name | Relationship with Robert Carnevale | Civil | Canon |
| Overbey, Henry | Husband of the 1st cousin 6 times removed | | |
| Page, Benjamin Tracy | Husband of the 3rd cousin | | |
| Page, Reagan Andrew | 3rd cousin once removed | IX | 5 |
| Page, Ryan Tracy | 3rd cousin once removed | IX | 5 |
| Paponek, Helen | Wife of the great-granduncle | | |
| Pavco, Cathrine | Wife of the granduncle | | |
| Pearson, Rhonda | Wife of the 1st cousin | | |
| Peg | Wife of the great-granduncle | | |
| Pemberton, Adeline | Wife of the 3rd great-granduncle | | |
| Pemberton, Thomas | Husband of the 3rd great-grandaunt | | |
| Peters, Barbara Ellen | Wife of the 2nd cousin once removed | | |
| Petulia | Wife of the 2nd great-grandfather | | |
| Piatt, Sarag Ekkeb Wilson | Wife of the 4th great-granduncle | | |
| Pitzer, Hannah | Wife of the 6th great-granduncle | | |
| Pitzer, Mary | Wife of the 6th great-granduncle | | |
| Porcella, Marybeth | Ex-wife of the brother | | |
| Pritchard, Samuel | Husband of the 4th great-grandaunt | | |
| Rachel | Wife of the 5th great-granduncle | | |
| Radica, Mary Nicolas | Wife of the granduncle | | |
| Ray, Alonzo | 1st cousin 4 times removed | VIII | 6 |
| Ray, Edward | 1st cousin 4 times removed | VIII | 6 |
| Ray, Joseph | 1st cousin 4 times removed | VIII | 6 |
| Ray, Mary Elizabeth | 1st cousin 4 times removed | VIII | 6 |
| Ray, Salathiel | 1st cousin 4 times removed | VIII | 6 |
| Ray, Thomas | Husband of the 3rd great-grandaunt | | |
| Ray, William | 1st cousin 4 times removed | VIII | 6 |
| Reagan, Alice Irene | 1st cousin twice removed | VI | 4 |
| Reagan, Anna Mary | Great-grandmother | III | 3 |
| Reagan, Anne Elizabeth | 3rd cousin | VIII | 4 |
| Reagan, Edward P | Great-granduncle | V | 4 |
| Reagan, Ella Kathryn | Great-grandaunt | V | 4 |
| Reagan, Emma Margaret | Great-grandaunt | V | 4 |
| Reagan, Forda | 1st cousin twice removed | VI | 4 |
| Reagan, Greta | 1st cousin twice removed | VI | 4 |
| Reagan, James | 1st cousin twice removed | VI | 4 |
| Reagan, James | Great-granduncle | V | 4 |
| Reagan, James | 1st cousin twice removed | VI | 4 |
| Reagan, Jean | 1st cousin twice removed | VI | 4 |
| Reagan, Jeffrey | 3rd cousin | VIII | 4 |
| Reagan, Joanna | 1st cousin twice removed | VI | 4 |
| Reagan, John | 1st cousin twice removed | VI | 4 |
| Reagan, John Joseph | 2nd cousin once removed | VII | 4 |
| Reagan, John Leo | 1st cousin twice removed | VI | 4 |
| Reagan, John Leo | 2nd cousin once removed | VII | 4 |
| Reagan, John Thomas | Great-granduncle | V | 4 |
| Reagan, Joseph | 1st cousin twice removed | VI | 4 |
| Reagan, Joseph Emmett | Great-granduncle | V | 4 |
| Reagan, Judy | 3rd cousin | VIII | 4 |
| Reagan, Kelly | 3rd cousin | VIII | 4 |
| Reagan, Kenneth | 2nd cousin once removed | VII | 4 |