| Name | Relationship with Michael Newlin | Civil | Canon |
| Toney, George C. | 1st cousin 5 times removed | IX | 7 |
| Toney, George Washington | 1st cousin 4 times removed | VIII | 6 |
| Toney, Hannah | 1st cousin 4 times removed | VIII | 6 |
| Toney, Harris | 1st cousin 6 times removed | X | 8 |
| Toney, Harris | 5th great-granduncle | IX | 8 |
| Toney, Hester | 1st cousin 4 times removed | VIII | 6 |
| Toney, Hiram | 1st cousin 4 times removed | VIII | 6 |
| Toney, Hiram | 3rd great-granduncle | VII | 6 |
| Toney, Honor | 6th great-grandaunt | X | 9 |
| Toney, Honor | 5th great-grandaunt | IX | 8 |
| Toney, Ibly | 1st cousin 4 times removed | VIII | 6 |
| Toney, James | 1st cousin 6 times removed | X | 8 |
| Toney, James | 6th great-granduncle | X | 9 |
| Toney, James Collins | 1st cousin 5 times removed | IX | 7 |
| Toney, Jean | 4th great-grandaunt | VIII | 7 |
| Toney, John | 1st cousin 5 times removed | IX | 7 |
| Toney, John | 1st cousin 6 times removed | X | 8 |
| Toney, John | 1st cousin 6 times removed | X | 8 |
| Toney, John | 7th great-granduncle | XI | 10 |
| Toney, John | 6th great-granduncle | X | 9 |
| Toney, John Henery | 1st cousin 4 times removed | VIII | 6 |
| Toney, Joyce | 5th great-grandaunt | IX | 8 |
| Toney, Lewis | 1st cousin 6 times removed | X | 8 |
| Toney, Maggie | Great-grandaunt | V | 4 |
| Toney, Maggie | Great-grandaunt | V | 4 |
| Toney, Mahala | 1st cousin 4 times removed | VIII | 6 |
| Toney, Margaret | 2nd great-grandaunt | VI | 5 |
| Toney, Marilda | 2nd great-grandaunt | VI | 5 |
| Toney, Mark | 7th great-granduncle | XI | 10 |
| Toney, Mary | 1st cousin 4 times removed | VIII | 6 |
| Toney, Mary | 5th great-grandaunt | IX | 8 |
| Toney, Mary A. Wyatte | Wife of the 3rd great-granduncle | | |
| Toney, Mary Anne (Polly) | 2nd great-grandaunt | VI | 5 |
| Toney, Matilda | 1st cousin 4 times removed | VIII | 6 |
| Toney, Maude | Great-grandaunt | V | 4 |
| Toney, Maude | Great-grandaunt | V | 4 |
| Toney, Melinda | 1st cousin 4 times removed | VIII | 6 |
| Toney, Melvin | 1st cousin 4 times removed | VIII | 6 |
| Toney, Micajah | 1st cousin 6 times removed | X | 8 |
| Toney, Nancy | 3rd great-grandaunt | VII | 6 |
| Toney, Noah | 1st cousin 4 times removed | VIII | 6 |
| Toney, Noah | 2nd great-granduncle | VI | 5 |
| Toney, Payton | 3rd great-granduncle | VII | 6 |
| Toney, Robert | 2nd great-granduncle | VI | 5 |
| Toney, Sally | Great-grandaunt | V | 4 |
| Toney, Sarah | 6th great-grandaunt | X | 9 |
| Toney, Sarah B. | 2nd great-grandaunt | VI | 5 |
| Toney, Serepta | Great-grandaunt | V | 4 |
| Wife of the half 1st cousin 3 times removed | | |
| Toney, Serepta Buck | Great-grandmother | III | 3 |