| Name | Relationship with Ryan Paul | Civil | Canon |
| Peek, Tonja | 4th cousin once removed | XI | 6 |
| Pegorick, Robert Jay | Husband of the 5th cousin once removed | | |
| Pennington, Heather Nadine | 8th cousin | XVIII | 9 |
| Pennington, Juanita Maria | 8th cousin | XVIII | 9 |
| Pennington, Michael Ray | Ex-husband of the 7th cousin once removed | | |
| Penniston, Charles | Husband of the 4th cousin twice removed | | |
| Perrone, Andrew | 3rd cousin once removed | IX | 5 |
| Perrone, Louis | Husband of the 2nd cousin twice removed | | |
| Peters, Apolonia Nata | Wife of the 3rd cousin 5 times removed | | |
| Peters, Carrie | 5th cousin once removed | XIII | 7 |
| Peters, Jamie | Wife of the 7th cousin once removed | | |
| Peters, Jordan | 5th cousin | XII | 6 |
| Peters, Melissa | 5th cousin once removed | XIII | 7 |
| Peters, Michael | Husband of the 4th cousin once removed | | |
| Peters, Roger | Husband of the 4th cousin twice removed | | |
| Peterson, Randall | Husband of the 4th cousin twice removed | | |
| Petrey, Erika E. | Ex-wife of the 7th cousin once removed | | |
| Petty, Lorraine | Wife of the 3rd cousin 3 times removed | | |
| Pezzetti, Mary | Wife of the 3rd cousin 3 times removed | | |
| Pflum, Aaren Janelle | 4th cousin once removed | XI | 6 |
| Pflum, Allison Elizabeth | 5th cousin | XII | 6 |
| Pflum, Ashley Janelle | 4th cousin once removed | XI | 6 |
| Pflum, Brayden Christopher | 5th cousin | XII | 6 |
| Pflum, Brooke Rashelle | 5th cousin | XII | 6 |
| Pflum, Casey Johnathan | 4th cousin once removed | XI | 6 |
| Pflum, Catherine Ann | Wife of the 6th cousin twice removed | | |
| Pflum, Darrell Edwin | 3rd cousin twice removed | X | 6 |
| Pflum, Denise Ann "DeeDee" | 3rd cousin twice removed | X | 6 |
| Pflum, Edwin "Tinny" | Husband of the 2nd cousin 3 times removed | | |
| Pflum, Jeffery Lee | 3rd cousin twice removed | X | 6 |
| Pflum, Kelly Christopher | 4th cousin once removed | XI | 6 |
| Pflum, Kevin Joseph | 3rd cousin twice removed | X | 6 |
| Pflum, Kevin Joseph | 4th cousin once removed | XI | 6 |
| Pflum, Kimberly Sue | 3rd cousin twice removed | X | 6 |
| Pflum, Marie Ann | Wife of the 5th cousin 3 times removed | | |
| Pflum, Phillip Jeffery | 4th cousin once removed | XI | 6 |
| Pflum, Victoria C. "Vikki" | 3rd cousin twice removed | X | 6 |
| Phillip, Leslie | Wife of the 7th cousin once removed | | |
| Phillips, Clara Amanda | Wife of the 2nd cousin 4 times removed | | |
| Phillips, Clifford | Husband of the 2nd cousin 4 times removed | | |
| Phillips, Michael Alan | Husband of the 5th cousin 3 times removed | | |
| Phillips, Paul Clifton | 3rd cousin 3 times removed | XI | 7 |
| Phillips, Tammy Lee | Wife of the 3rd cousin twice removed | | |
| Pickens, Barbara Sue | 4th cousin once removed | XI | 6 |
| Pickens, Christopher Allen | 4th cousin once removed | XI | 6 |
| Pickens, Gilbert Earl | Husband of the 3rd cousin twice removed | | |
| Pickens, Kristina Alexandra | 5th cousin | XII | 6 |
| Pierce, Scarlett Rose | Wife of the 1st cousin twice removed | | |
| Pierog, Jonathan R. | Half 2nd cousin once removed | VII | 4 |
| Pierog, Matthew R. | Half 2nd cousin once removed | VII | 4 |